Blog

  • Test Prep Courses
  • STEAM Camps
  • CLUBS

Blog

Can kids truly learn in virtual classrooms?

Virtual learning comes in a variety of ways. This past school year, students across the United States began pursuing their education in a virtual learning environment. The transition online has not been without sweat, and many of us have stopped and wondered: are students really learning in their online classes? Opinions on the matter can be polarizing, but a large meta-analysis from the Department of Education gives us three key reasons to be optimistic.

Share This Post

Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on email

This past school year, to a varying extent, every student in America was called upon to become a virtual learner. For some, the transition has meant easier access to school, and impromptu training in working in the digital world. Unfortunately, that experience is not universal in the slightest. Many students feel left behind and adrift in the newfangled obstacles distance learning comes with. The question many parents and policymakers are asking is: does virtual learning work? Sure, most students can get comfy in front of their computer and attend class, but are students truly learning? More broadly, can they?

The answer to that question is hardly straightforward. We’ve all heard anecdotes of virtual learning horror stories, if not lived one, but generally, students are adapting quickly. Although virtual learning environments have been developed and implemented over the past two decades, few reliable studies have been published on the efficacy of virtual learning for students K-12. In a lot of ways, the state of education in the United States is uncharted territory. Luckily, the relatively small collection of reliable, peer-reviewed virtual learning studies gives us good reason to think this younger generation of learners is taking well to virtual learning.

The U.S. Department of Education published the “Evaluation of Evidence-Based Practices in Online Learning” back in 2010, which served as a meta-analysis of thousands of virtual learning studies. Ultimately, the analysts narrowed their sources to include only studies that specifically contrasted virtual learning with traditional classrooms and measured student learning outcomes. The results of this meta-analysis lead researchers to three key findings on the efficacy of online learning.

Students Learn (Marginally) More Online

As shocking as it may seem, students who received instruction virtually slightly outperformed those learning the same material in class. Intuitively, what might think virtual learners might be at a disadvantage in their digital classrooms. However, when faced with the same content, students whose curriculum was taught online kept up fine with those learning in brick-and-mortar schools. Furthermore, students learning virtually surpassed those receiving traditional face to face instruction in learning outcomes.

Online Teachers Need To Be Active

Virtual learning comes in a few varieties. The course structure from one to the next is largely dictated by the institution hosting online classes. Virtual learning environments, VLE’s, can look quite different, but researchers concluded one of the most important facets of effective virtual classrooms was an instructor at the helm. Depending on the VLE, students may receive instructor directed lessons, or students may not receive any lessons from the teacher themselves. In classrooms without teachers leading students directly, students may be expected to cover content on their own or click through web-guided lessons. However, students are far better served with attentive teachers to work closely with, akin to the course structure at Tip-Top Brain.

Most of the Differences Between Online and Traditional Learning Don’t Matter

The meta-analysis identified and isolated twelve variables across the studies surveyed. Ultimately, the only two variables that caused a significant difference in student learning outcomes were the aforementioned learning type (online or in-person) and teacher involvement (synchronous vs. asynchronous.) Whereas other variables, like the use of textbooks, or pedagogy seemed to have little to no effect on student learning outcomes.

In many ways, the debate over virtual learning efficacy isn’t quite over. The shift in schooling has been swift, and not without some growing pains. We’ll likely be watching the state of virtual learning evolve over the course of this coming school year, but fortunately, there is strong reason to believe virtual learning is extremely effective.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get updates and learn from the best

More To Explore

The Pros & Cons of Different Virtual Learning Environments

Not sure which virtual learning model would best serve your child? The choice can certainly be challenging, as each has its own strengths and weaknesses. Read on for the most common arguments for and against the three most common virtual learning environment formats.

Tip-Top Brain Talks Summer Brain Drain

Summer Brain Drain or Learning Slide…the all too familiar words. What is it? What causes it? And how can you help prevent it from consuming your child? The answers lie below.

Please complete this form and our program coordinator will reach out to you shortly.

Our response time is within 24 hours
glowing arrow

We're committed to your privacy. Tip-Top Brain uses the information you provide to us to contact you about our relevant content and services. You may unsubscribe from these communications at any time.